Maladaptive? Maybe Unsustainable Hits Closer to Home
By Bri Murray and Sandi James CEDC, PhD Cand
Maladaptive is a term that is thrown around in psychology often used to describe behaviors deemed problematic. If I had a dollar every time a provider used that term to describe my eating disorder, treatment would have been far more financially accessible. The Oxford English Dictionary defines “maladaptive” as “not providing adequate or appropriate adjustment to the environment or situation.”
But here’s the thing: My eating disorder didn’t arise from a lack of adjustment. It was a survival mechanism – a coping mechanism that made sense given the context of my life. I developed my eating disorder at eleven, amidst relentless bullying about my physical disability. The message was clear: if I worked hard enough, I could erase my disability. My peers were cruel, telling me I would have friends if only I chose to walk normally.
As a child, I didn’t know how to navigate this cruelty. I mean, who would at such a young age? An eating disorder seemed like an answer, a way to control something in a world where I felt utterly powerless. I don’t think I would have survived my childhood without it. It sounds ironic, but my eating disorder was not maladaptive.
It allowed me to live through some of the most difficult moments of my life, and I’m not alone. Through years of group therapy for my Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), I’ve heard countless similar stories. Fifty percent of individuals with eating disorders also meet the criteria for PTSD (Brewerton et al., 2020).
To label my eating disorder as “maladaptive” implies a personal failing, a lack of adequate coping. It ignores the reality: there were no healthy coping mechanisms available to an eleven-year-old facing relentless bullying and abandonment from the adults who should have protected me. My eating disorder was an invaluable resource in an extremely traumatic time. Two things can be true at once. I wish I had better resources and I’m grateful I found a way to survive.
The word “maladaptive” carries a negative connotation. It suggests the available coping mechanism is ineffective, unhelpful, and perhaps even a hindrance.
I didn’t choose to be bullied or disabled. My eating disorder was a response, a desperate attempt to survive. When providers use “maladaptive” they inadvertently criticize my survival choices, ignoring the lack of viable alternatives. I believe good intentions often blind them to this impact.
Ruth Elliott, LICSW, the Director of Clinical Services at MEDA, offers a more compassionate perspective. She prefers “unsustainable” when referring to eating disorders. This word shifts the focus from the individual to the behavior, acknowledging the eating disorder itself as unsustainable rather than the person. It also removes the implication that I could have simply chosen a “better” coping mechanism.
“Unsustainable” resonates with me. It acknowledges the desperate circumstances that fueled my eating disorder without judgment. It recognizes the need for healing and change without blaming the victim. It allows for compassion and understanding.
Let’s move away from “maladaptive” and embrace a language that acknowledges the complexity of trauma and the resilience of the human spirit. Let’s focus on healing not judgment.
References
Brewerton, T., Perlman, M., Gavidia, I., Suro, G., Genet, J., Bunnell, D. (2020). The association of traumatic events and posttraumatic stress disorder with greater eating disorder and comorbid symptom severity in residential eating disorder treatment centers. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 53(12), 2061–2066. https://doi.org/10.1002/eat.23401

